Below are Middletown's Records at each of the five stadiums they have played at since 1895.

1895 - 1911
Asylum Field
29-6-6
 

1912 - 1931
Hayes Field
52-22-5
 

1930 - 1981
Wilson Field
124-87-10
 

1982 - 2006
"Old" Faller Field
69-46-2

2007
All games were played on the road while Middie Stadium was being constructed.

2008 - Present
Middie Stadium @ Faller Field
4-12 

All-Time Home Winning % - 60%